0114 4199 819
Principal: Steve Butler MRICS Chartered Surveyor16 High Street, Staveley, S43 3UX
8.30am to 6.30pm Monday to Friday
Expert Witness Reports
Our Sheffield surveyors have advised owners of properties about defective roofs over a number of years. The most common problems with pitched roofs seen are life expired slate, usually because the nails have corroded, and frost damaged tiles. Problems with flat roofs are usually due to poor choice of a deck material combined with poor ventilation which results in the deck deteriorating. The other problem with flat roofs is a lack of maintenance. Felt roofs in particular are very vulnerable to damage caused by heat and need annual maintenance after a period of time. The nature of the most other problems that we have seen have been inflicted by rouge builders who have little if any training or experience of dealing with roofs. Structural problems are usually caused by interference from DIY enthusiasts and rouge builders attempting conversion and extensions.
Our surveyors can advise on whether and what type of repair and maintenance of older roofs require. We can also write reports where there has been poor workmanship for use in court. However, the nature of rouge builders is that judgements are hard to enforce against them and we recommend that clients check out the prospects of recovering any money from proceedings before risking more money in what can be expensive court proceedings that often drag out for years.
Here the builder did not understand the cause of water ingress and went on to largely recover the whole of the front face of the roof which was completely un-warranted and done in a very poor manner. The builder also claimed to have recovered the rear face of the roof but we could find no evidence that this had actually been done.
Here most of the failures were due to poor planning before laying any tiles.
This Sheffield roof has been un-necessarily recovered by cow boy roofers with a novel drainage idea for a flat roof. The work was poorly carried out and they managed to fall through the ceiling of a flat roof.
Poor recovering of a shallow pitched roof in Sheffield that our surveyors considered was likely to have been life expired.
Here the properties had very shalllow roofs in an attempt to save money. The problem is that overtime the tiles wear and the overlaps become vulnerable to penetration in driving rain or particualry snow which is very fine. Not content with making a poor job of the subject properties roof the roofer had sawn through the battens on the adjacent property leaving their tiles unsupported. Tiles were laid at inadequate overlap for the fall of the roof and the potential for rain penetration was exacerbated by loose lining sheets.